Sam reminds Troy that identical twins may share DNA but they don't have the same fingerprints. Max hovers over Blair as she recuperates at Dorian's. Meanwhile, Gabrielle slips into the house and dons a flimsy negligee. Struggling to keep Jen from discovering the naked girl in his bed, Cris seeks to distract her by revealing how he's planned a romantic getaway just for two. Blair tells Max how Todd walked out on her when she was doubled over with pain. At the Break Bar, Seth and Jessica learn about the "Hottie Bares All" website. Nora convinces Troy to let himself be fingerprinted to clear up any confusion about his identity. Across the room, R.J. quietly points out to Lindsay how much trouble she'll be in if "Troy" proves to be Colin after all. Max awakens from an erotic dream to find a scantily clad Gabrielle smothering him with kisses. Upstairs, Blair regretfully wishes she had come clean with Todd long ago. Finally pulling away from Gabrielle's embrace, Max orders her to leave. Shauna plants a kiss on Cristian, who reminds his "fan" of his commitment to Jen. After comparing the two sets of fingerprints, Antonio confirms that Troy is not Colin.
Nora has a nightmare that she waking up next to Colin in a red-satin sheet bed. "Hello, Scarlet!" says Colin as Nora wakes up screaming. Sam comes in her bedroom to comfort her. Sam convinces Nora to take some time to herself to relax. Meanwhile at the diner, Will and Jen are discussing her relationship with Cris when Troy walks in. He approaches them and Jen shrieks. Will practically assaults Troy until he has a chance to explain that he is Colin's twin. Will demands he leaves town, but Troy informs them that he has family business to attend to. Troy leaves and soon after Sam arrives. Jen and Sam have a heart to heart about Jen becoming an adult. Jen pries into Sam's personal life by asking if he and Nora are getting back together. At Llantano Mountain, Nora is taking a nap in the sun, but is awakened by a soaking wet and shirtless Troy standing over her!
Kelly goes to Llanfair to say goodbye to Jessica. She tells Jess that she wants to be with Kevin and Duke in Texas. They reminisce about when a wild and crazy Kelly flew into Llanview. After Kelly leaves, Natalie shows up to return the dress she borrowed from Jess. Natalie reveals that she can't afford to stay at Llanview U. Upset, Jess offers to loan her the money for tuition. Natalie declines, but Jess thinks she can help her get a job.
Gabrielle hires a hot looking man-nurse to look after Blair. Max fires him on the spot. Max demands to know what Gab's interest in Blair is. Gab feeds him some garbage about being a changed woman, but Max isn't buying it. Gab informs Max she knows he doesn't love Blair. He can't however, bring himself to kick Gab out of the house. Kelly arrives to see Blair and warns her to be on guard. Kelly is afraid someone could find out the truth about the baby. Blair and Kelly say a tearful goodbye. Blair is sad that she doesn't have anyone to confide in. After Kelly leaves, Gabrielle wanders in. Blair is snippy with her, but Gab responds sweetly and moves in to fluff Blair's pillows and tuck her into bed. Unfortunately for Blair, Gab finds her pregnancy pad!
Cris and Seth help Carlotta out at the diner and reminisce about old times. Leah stops by with a confirmation for Cris' special weekend with Jen and admires Seth, asking Cris to give him her number. Seth later admits to Cris that he's interested in Jess while Cris tells him he's ok with it. They touch on the subject of computers but Cris is still unaware of what's happening at the bar.
Natalie is dropping out of school because she needs a job, but Jess convinces her to take a loan. She'll help out with the job and suggests that she can be her mother's social secretary. Ben and Viki arrive home and run into Sam at the door who informs them of Troy's appearance in Llanview. He admits that Nora is on fragile ground due to this. Once they get in the house Jess pulls her mother aside to fill her in on Natalie though Viki appears to be acting strangely. She in turn fills Jess in on Colin's twin and tells her she would have preferred to discuss Natalie's situation alone. Jess plays up her friend by telling her mother that she's nice, smart, can do anything and most of all, needs the job to stay in school. In the study, Viki gives Natalie an interview on the spot and agrees to hire her. Out in the foyer, Ben and Sam have a chat; Ben informs his brother that he can see he still loves Nora. Sam, on the other hand, thinks that Nora just needs her space but Ben disagrees. She needs Sam, Ben says, and though Sam is hesitant due to their parting previously, he decides to go after her. Jess introduces her step-dad to Natalie who thinks he's really cute. Viki jokes that her daughter twisted her arm to get her friend the job.
Nora is sunning when she is approached by Troy who won't let her leave by grabbing her. She threatens bodily harm and he lets go, apologizing. He stopped at the lake on the spur of the moment and was not following her as she accuses. He tells her about the talisman that he is wearing that was carved from a tree in Kenya. He was sprung on them in an unlikely manner which is why they've all been unkind, she tells him. He only wants to know why she killed Colin. Though she informs him that it's public record she tells him the entire story from start to finish, along with the fact that she's lost many of her memories. Colin went over the edge though no one is able to explain why other than it appears that he became obsessed with her. Nora is very insistent that she won't apologize and in fact, would do it again if she had to. Troy apologizes for his brother but Nora tells him it isn't necessary. As he touches her in comfort, Sam approaches.
Gabrielle finds Blair's pregnancy padding though Blair at first claims it's been used as a pillow. Gabrielle knows what it really is and is beginning to think that maybe the baby isn't Max's but Todd's, she says. Blair denies it but Gabi presses until Blair finally admits to the con that she was originally planning to pull until she learned that she really was pregnant. When Gabi wants to know why it's laying so close at hand, Blair tells her that Kelly dropped it off as a good-bye present for a joke. When Gabi wants to call Max and fill him in on the joke, Blair threatens to tell him about how slowly Gabi dialed 9-1-1 when she needed them. It's a standoff but there's one condition, Gabi announces. Blair has to cut Max loose.
Rae visits to speak with a patient but doesn't have any information since the file hasn't arrived yet according to one of the nuns. The woman's name is Allison Perkins and she tells Ms. Cummings that she's done a terrible thing. She hurt someone and though Rae says otherwise, she can't be forgiven. She won't tell her anything about it. After the visit, Rae tells the nun that the patient is deeply troubled, carrying a large burden of guilt. The file has arrived and Rae peruses it. She mutters "Viki" and looks at the woman in shock.
Natalie thanks Jess again for getting her the job with her mother and now she'll be able to give a check to the registrar. Seth approaches to chat with Jess but just then Det. Sykes appears. He tells Jess that the stuck elevator that she was on was deliberately tampered with.