Hope and Jennifer continued their chat but were interrupted when Shawn and Bo arrived at home. Bo suggested a "boys night out" and decided to take J.T. along with them. As they left, Hope joked not to vote anyone out of the tribe. When they were gone, Jennifer told Hope what a wonderful family she had.
Hope wanted to hear more about "this Colin guy," but Jennifer said that she thought it was all in her head. She called herself pathetic, but Hope promised not to judge her. She said that she felt that Jack had even more power over her than before. She explained how when Colin had left Africa, she had followed him to Ireland and that he hadn't been pleased to see her there. He had told her that he had thought of her as a "chum" and nothing more. She talked about how nice he had been to her in Africa and said she had truly thought he had cared for her.
Jennifer said that once they had been in Ireland, Colin had treated her differently and had ended up sneaking off. She called herself a "love-struck teenage girl," but she was actually relieved that she would never see him again. She told Hope that she felt like an idiot for following him and that he was out of her league. Hope reassured her that she was beautiful and intelligent and would never be out of anyone's league. Jennifer appreciated the kindness and thanked Hope for being such a good friend, but she needed go home to Jack. Hope had an idea and invited Jennifer to spend the night there, and Jennifer decided to take her up on her offer. Certain she could get home before Abby woke up, she wasn't even going to call Jack to tell him where she was.
Bo, Shawn, and J.T. arrived at the pub, much to the delight of Grandpa Shawn and Caroline. Shawn and Bo joked about how neglected they were over all the attention J.T. was getting. Grandpa Shawn and Caroline hauled him away to show him off to everyone as Bo and Shawn talked about how Bo's attitude had changed toward J.T. in the past few months. Grandpa Shawn decided to call his sister in Ireland, and he asked if all was okay. Colin explained he was lying low after all the trouble Bo had caused there. He told Shawn to keep Bo away.
Back at the table, Bo questioned Shawn about girls, dating, and such -- and about Belle Black in particular. Shawn got kind of flustered as Caroline returned with J.T. Bo called J.T. his buddy and couldn't imagine life without him.
Jack was asleep on the couch and heard a noise outside. He jumped up, thinking it was Jennifer then he thought it was a burglar. Actually, it was Greta stopping by with some accessories for the house. She decided to leave them at the door and sneak away quietly. However, Jack rushed out the door with a frying pan as a weapon and fell over the stuff. He invited her in and didn't even offer to help her.
Greta lectured Jack on how to treat women. He took note and went for tea. Greta wondered how Jennifer put up with him. Jack loved all the stuff she had picked out, and Greta hoped Jennifer liked it as well. He didn't know where she was and thought Jennifer was trying to teach him a lesson.
Abby went downstairs, looking for her mom, as Jack joked about the "princess" and called her "Lady Abigail." Greta started to leave as Jack offered Abby a cupcake. Outside, Greta thought he was really weird -- but that he was a good father. Jack and Abby enjoyed their cupcakes, and Abby had icing all over her face. Abby asked again where mommy was. Jack changed the subject and sent her off to bed then he wondered where Jennifer was as well.
At the DiMera mansion, Lexie rang the doorbell, but Stefano wouldn't let Abe answer it. The phone rang, and Stefano said it was probably Lexie and for Abe to get it. It was Celeste, who was in a panic, telling Abe about Glen, Barb, and the lawyer at the door. Abe told her he would be right there and not to panic. He stormed off as Lexie hid in the bushes.
After Abe was gone, Lexie walked in, and Stefano handed the phone to her. She gave Celeste instructions on how to handle the situation. She told her to take the papers and be polite. After it was done, Glen and Barb wondered what was going on and what the Carvers were up to.
Lexie assured her mom that Abe would be there soon and that she would call back in five minutes to talk to him. Abe rushed in and demanded to know where Lexie was. Lexie was furious with her father and demanded the truth. They bickered, and she told him that she knew that Glen was the father of Hope's baby.
Lexie called and talked to Abe as he bombarded her with questions. She told him that she was at Stefano's, and they were going to dinner. Abe fumed. She told him that Stefano and Brandon were trying to help her and for him to just trust her, much to Abe's dismay. After getting off the phone, Abe asked Celeste what was going on. She prattled on and on about Stefano's involvement until Able blew his top. He apologized to her and went to make some calls. After he was gone, to herself, she said she'd always had a feeling that Isaac would be taken away from them.
At the DiMera mansion, Lexie and Stefano got into it again, and she demanded the truth. She told him about switching the DNA samples with Hope's baby, and Stefano was shocked. She told him that she had already known that Bo wasn't the father and wondered how Glen had gotten Hope pregnant. She demanded to know what he was not telling her about the situation. Stefano said that he had already told her everything and assured her that Glen was not the father of Hope's baby. She wanted to know how he could be so sure and said that if Stefano was so sure that Glen wasn't the father, that meant that he knew who was.
Mimi and Jan were at .com, checking out the operagirl.net website. Jason nearly caught them, but they covered. Jan planned to broadcast the video of Chloe showering on the big-screen television monitors at the Last Blast dance. She was sure that Philip would dump Chloe in a nanosecond when he saw that video.
Chloe and Belle were in Belle's room, discussing the pros and cons of Eminem, when Philip called. They agreed to meet Philip and Shawn at .com, and when Chloe hung up, Belle suggested taking Brady along. Downstairs, John told Brady that he was very proud of Brady for keeping his cool after losing the case. Brady gave John a sob story about how he felt like a prisoner in the penthouse, and Marlena heard every word. She stormed into the living room, amazed that John would allow Brady to lie about her like that.
Marlena blew up at Brady, but Belle arrived downstairs with Chloe and interrupted the argument. Brady was more than willing to tag along with Belle and Chloe, since doing so would get him away from Marlena. Before leaving, though, Belle demanded to know what was happening with Marlena and Brady, so Marlena explained what had happened earlier. Belle told John that she believed Marlena -- Brady was a great actor, and he was stringing John along.
Outside, Brady and Chloe started to argue again. Belle emerged from the penthouse and interrupted them, and they headed off to .com. Inside, John told Marlena that hearing Belle say what she had said about Brady had made him realize that she was right -- Brady was playing John. He apologized to Marlena for being so clueless.
Philip and Shawn arrived at .com and started talking to Jan and Mimi. Jan antagonized Philip, telling him that Chloe had him wrapped around her finger, and Jason joined in. Philip went off on Jason, and they got into a fight. Chloe, Belle, and Brady arrived in time to watch Philip knock Jason to the ground -- and Jason didn't get up. Belle thought they should call the police.
Hope told Bo that she wanted to have another child with him, which led to another discussion about J.T.'s true paternity. Bo told Hope that he couldn't handle not knowing; it was killing him. Hope begged him to leave it alone and accept J.T. as theirs, but Bo wanted to follow some leads he had and try to track down the true father. Bo told Hope that the father had to be someone that Gina had loved, and then he realized it had to be John. Hope assured Bo that they'd been down that road before, and John couldn't be the father. Bo seemed to buy it but wasn't ready to give up searching for the father. Hope got a bit seductive in order to get Bo's mind off of J.T.'s paternity, and they began to make love.
Lexie told Stefano that she knew that Bo wasn't J.T's father -- and she thought Stefano knew who the father was. He tried to deny it, but Lexie had had enough of his lies and demanded the truth. As Stefano continued to evade the question, Lexie began to put the pieces of the puzzle together and realized that Hope had Marlo's baby, and Lexie had Hope's baby. Stefano tried to assure Lexie that that kind of thing only happened in the movies, but Lexie wasn't convinced.
Lexie remembered that on the day that J.T. and Isaac had been born, Lexie and Hope had both thought for a second that their babies had looked different than they had the last time that they had seen the babies, which only made her more certain. She was sure that she and Hope were going to lose their babies. Stefano was furious with Lexie for switching the DNA -- everything would have been fine if she'd just let Stefano handle it, he said. Lexie realized that Stefano had always been sure that things would work out, and she asked if he'd had something to do with the switch. He denied the accusation, and Lexie believed him.
Lexie told Stefano that she had to tell Hope that she had the wrong baby, but Stefano forbade her from doing so. Lexie panicked, telling Stefano that the lab was going to do another test the next morning and that when the results were in, she'd lose her baby. Stefano told her he'd take care of everything, but she had to agree to trust him and follow his instructions to the letter. Lexie agreed -- she'd do anything to keep Isaac.