At the Cory's, Rachel receives the package from Denver for Carl. Carl comes downstairs and Rachel gives him the package. Carl accepts the package and then casually walks back into the living room where Felicia was waiting. Rachel joins Carl in the living room with Felicia, as Felicia ask her friends if Cory Publishing has any copies of her first novel Embers In The Snow. She then explains to them that everything in the novel has been reenacted into the present day and she's very worried about Cass. Felicia told them the character she modeled after Cass, (Winthrop Crass) gets killed in Embers in The Snow but she can't remember how. Carl told her that Embers In the Snow was out of print, but Cory Publishing has a copy of it on their database. Carl went into the study to retrieve the file on database. Felicia tries to find out more about the Matthew situation, but Rachel told her she isn't up to discussing Matthew right now. Carl returns and told her that Embers In the Snow was no longer in their database. Rachel says it must be an accident, they have a lot of new staff and someone might have misplaced it. Felicia told her she doesn't believe in accidents then rushes off to warn Cass. Carl and Rachel then turn their attentions onto the package. As Carl opens it, he finds out it's his appointment book he's been looking for. Rachel questions him about how it ended up in Denver where Chris Chapin died.
At the Airport, Jake ask Marley what happened at the funeral to cause her to leave and flee town like she's doing. Marley told Jake she doesn't want to talk about it. But Jake's constant nagging ends up making Marley tell Jake that Vicky was the one he needs to talk to. When Jake ask Marley if she was mad at Vicky, Marley denies it. Jake then speculates that she couldn't handle saying farewell to Michael. Marley elects to let her brother-in-law believe that instead of revealing the terrible truth.
Cass brought Donna home from the funeral and lends her some moral support remembering what it was like when he lost Frankie. Donna starts to feel a little better and told Cass he doesn't have to babysit her anymore and he can leave. Upon Cass exiting, Donna checks her answering service and receives a message from Jake. He told her he was going to stop Marley from leaving town. Donna then calls Vicky to warn her that Jake has gone to the airport to catch up to Marley.
At Vicky and Jake's Place, Grant tries to discuss Kirkland's welfare to an unsettling Vicky. Grant told Vicky he thinks with all the emotional turmoil going on, maybe it would be best if Kirkland spent the night with him. Aware of what angle Grant was coming from, Vicky told him he was not going to use this situation to get Kirkland from her. Grant told her that's not what he's trying to do and adds that Kirkland see's his place as a safe and secure place and that was why he ran away. Vicky told him she doesn't want Kirkland growing up sheltered the way Grant was. She says Kirkland was going to grow up learning how to express his feelings not suppress them like Grant's been taught. Grant told her Spencer supplied him with a lot of love and affection. Vicky cuts him off saying that was why Grant was so selfish and self-centered. Grant then told her he's not accusing her of anything and he thinks she just needs a break. Grant ask her to let Kirkland stay with him for tonight, but Vicky yells back "Over My Dead Body." Just then the phone rings, it's Donna calling to tell Vicky about Jake going to the airport after Marley. Panicked, Vicky told Kirkland to grab was coat so they can go. Grant told Vicky he'll stay there until her and Jake return. Taking Grant up on his offer, Vicky leaves for the airport.
Back at the Airport, Marley doesn't want to talk about the funeral or Vicky. Jake suspects she knows more than she's saying. Jake then ask Marley if he's mad at Vicky because she spent more time with Michael than Marley did. Marley told him that was not the reason and she chose to leave Bay City years ago. Jake tries to comfort Marley by saying how proud of Michael was of her, and Marley realizes just how much Jake has changed. She then told him that Vicky was lucky to have a man like him in her life. Feeling unworthy of Marley's kind words, Jake feels ashamed of himself. Sensing that something was wrong Marley ask Jake if she said something wrong. Jake then told her he knows who was responsible for the accident. Jake then told Marley about how he wanted Shane out of their lives so badly he wished him dead. He then told her back when everyone was praying for a miracle cure for Shane, he was practically standing over Shane's grave with a shovel. Marley told Jake it wasn't his fault and he's not to blame then adds that it's time for her to go. Jake tries to convince her to stay and tell him what happened between her and Vicky that would make her leave. Marley refuses to tell Jake anything. Just then, Vicky shows up and she told Marley to go on and tell Jake the truth. Marley covers by telling Jake that she can't stand to look at Vicky. She adds, looking at Vicky was like looking at a reflection of herself in the mirror and seeing the pain her eyes reflecting back on her. Marley told Jake it's like that with all of them, him, the boys, and Donna included. Marley then told them she has to go. Vicky ask Jake to give them a moment alone. Vicky told Marley she would have understood if she told Jake the truth. Marley told her it's not up to her to clear Vicky's conscience for her. Marley then told her if she had never married Jake and stayed on Shane's boat that day, Michael and Shane would have still been alive. Then she adds that Vicky chose to go up to the cabin in one of the worst storms possible to make love to Shane. Vicky told Marley that she never slept with Shane that night. She knew when she was alone with Shane that it was Jake who she really loved and that's why they were on the road that night. She was frantic to get back home to Jake. Marley congratulates Vicky, and then told her she can never be happy because she has lost her father and she lost a part of herself too, her sister. Marley then told Vicky if she would have told Jake the truth tonight and ruined her marriage, she would always wonder was she really did it because she wanted Jake for herself. With those last words, Marley walks off and boards the plane. Vicky watches with sadness as her twin leaves, then she and Jake leave to go home.
Back at Jake and Vicky's, Grant and Kirkland are playing games and Grant ask his son if he would like to be able to do this all the time. Kirkland told his dad yes, when his mommy gets over her nightmares. Grant ask Kirkland about Vicky's nightmares she's been having. Kirkland responds by saying, mommy keeps having nightmares about Shane. As Grant delights upon hearing this juicy piece of tidbits.
Over at Carlino's, Felicia catches up to Cass and told him she has to tell him something. Still angry about being the villain in Felicia's book, Cass gives Felicia a chilly welcome. Ignoring Cass's mood towards her, Felicia sits down to explain that something terrible happens to Winthrop Crass in Embers In the Snow. Cass casually wonders if his character loses his money or something like that, but Felicia informs him that Winthrop Crass gets murdered in Embers In the Snow.
Back at home, Jake and Vicky think about all that Marley said to them and Vicky excuses herself to go outside. Once outside, Vicky stares up at the sky and counts the stars. Above her was Marley's plane and Marley told her sister a tearful goodbye. Feeling Marley's presence and sensing her, Vicky stares up into the sky at the plane passing by and told Marley goodbye as well.
It was late in the evening and Gary was sitting at Toni's desk in the police department waiting for Josie to get through with her shift. Gary was looking on Toni" desk and finds a paper; he picks it up. Toni jumps on him about looking at her open cases she was working on and Gary says it was not snooping when the case isn't open at the present time. Josie was talking with Joe about the file Joe was holding ---it's the file on the fire at his house. Josie wants to know if he was going to open it again for investigation. Joe says no and throws it in the trash. Josie says Paulina may have been telling truth all along, Joe says no and brought up the lab work at the hospital showed drugs in Paulina' blood test. Josie says "Don't let circumstantial evidence keep them apart."
Josie told Gary that she was about ready to leave. This sidetracks Toni and Gary from snooping around her desk. Joe told Gary he needs to talk to him. He ask Gary what he thinks about the fire and Gary told him he was a fool to let his always following the book rules destroy his and Paulina's marriage. Gary brought up the fact that not only he believes Paulina was telling the truth but Jake and her family and Josie all believe Paulina, why can't Joe? This gets Joe to thinking about the file and the fire.
In the meantime, Carl and Rachel open the box that came in the mail earlier in the day. It was the appointment book that Carl has been looking for all day. It came from the same hotel that Chris Chapin had committed suicide at. Carl told Rachel and Amanda about being in Denver the day of Chapin's death. He insisted that Chapin had died during the day and not at night. Carl asked if Rachel believed him. She said that she did. Amanda did not answer and walked away. Carl left to go to talk to Felicia.
Felicia was at Carlino's talking to Cass. She has bad news about the character in her book that Cass was supposed to be like in the mystery surrounding them of late. Felicia told Cass that Crass (the character in the book) is killed---but the her book was missing and she can't remember how he dies. This does not thrill Cass at all. In fact he was real upset that he was even considered this character. He told Felicia again that he feels that Wally was the one behind the break-in, the getaway hotel set up and the book being missing. Carl arrives and told Felicia he has two leads to check up on and that he will get to the bottom of the missing book. Carl leaves and a man in camouflage clothing was peeking into Carlino's at Cass and Felicia, it was Wally. Both Cass and Felicia see him and Cass runs out after him. He does not catch him and returned to tell Felicia that he was going to the police. They leave the restaurant and Wally was skulking around behind them.
Paulina and Jake are talking at Jakes and Vicky's house, she is about to leave and Jake ask her to stay and talk. They discuss the problems she and Joe are having and that Joe never was going to believe her about the fire. Jake says he knows that he will come around but Paulina says she misses him so much that she was going to tell Joe that yes she did start the fire. Jake told her not to lie that love can't be based on a lie. Paulina says that Jake and Vicky have a marriage where they both don't lie, Jake agrees.
Back at the police station Joe was having second thought about the file, the fire and Toni comes in telling him about a case she just closed and the evidence that pointed to someone was not the real cause of the case. This gets Joe thinking some more, he gets the file out of the trash and starts looking at it.
Gary and Josie get home and Gary wants to know what her and Toni had been talking about. Josie told him that they talked about having a family. Gary said in time they will, but that he needed time. Josie went to get ready for a shower and Gary takes out the paper he was looking at while at the police department. It was about J.C. Sinclair being arrested and that the case against him was still pending Josie returned in and Gary puts the paper away.
At the Cory estate Rachel was waiting up for Carl and Amanda comes in. They discuss the trust and love that they have for each other and the fact that Carl no longer trusts Amanda. Amanda was tempted to look in Carl's appointment book. She calls Allie at school and visits with her, she needs to look up some dates Allie gives her and she opens Carl's book. After the call Amanda tries to show Rachel something. Rachel takes the book and closes it, making sure that Amanda understands she trust Carl. Carl comes home and they head upstairs.
Its morning in BC and Sophia awakes to find a shirtless Nick staring out a window. She asks if he wants to talk and he says no. She then says she'll leave him alone but he replies he doesn't want that either. What he does want, Nick says, was her and they proceed to kiss passionately. Meanwhile, Lila was awaken by persistent knocking on her door. Irritated, she answers it to find Matt who wants to hurry her along to the doctor's office for a paternity test.
The scene opens to Jake and Joe having some type of confrontation in Joe's new apartment while Paulina tries to mediate. Before Jake leaves, he warns Joe not to hurt Paulina, the best friend he has right now (gee -- I thought Vicky was supposed to be his best friend). Paulina comments on the apartment and Joe says that it least Dante likes it. Paulina replies that it doesn't take much to make Dante happy -- he's just like his mom.
Things get hot and heavy between Sophia and Nick but she suddenly pulls away. He asks what's wrong -- isn't this what she wants? Sophia hems and haws and says she definitely wants him and has been imagining it for so long and how beautiful it will be...BUT. That definitely breaks the moment and Nick jumps up saying he won't force her. Sophia tries to bring him back and pleads they continue but he blows up at her to leave him alone. Matt happens to be lurking outside the apartment and busts in when he hears Nick yelling. A furious Nick demands to know what he was doing there and then storms out, saying he needs to get away from there. Matt asks a tearful Sophia what happened she says it was nothing, that Nick needs someone to take care of him because of his dad but Matt asks who will take care of her (the end of this scene made me gag -- Sophia and Matt are wearing on my last nerve).
At Josie and Gary's apartment, Josie confides in Toni how now Gary suddenly doesn't want a family and she thinks it might have to do with his reluctance to talk about his family. Toni advises her not to push but both the women's curiosity are piqued when a registered letter arrives for Gary from a federal prison in California. Josie ponders whether to open it when Nick arrives for a heart to heart.
Gary comes by to see Lila and comforts her as she rants about how Vicky is still coming between her and Shane. She told him about Shane's will and how Vicky was in charge of all his research. Lila confesses that Shane never knew about the baby and that his last words were Shane. She laments how Shane always took care of them and that he was her family. Gary hugs her and says that he and Josie help take care of her and that family isn't always what it was cracked up to be.