At the Cory's Matt and Carl's discussion of Chris Chapin was interrupted by Rachel who has just got off the phone with Nancy. She informs them that Chris Chapin was dead. Matt immediately points the finger at Carl, but Rachel cuts him off by saying "it was a suicide." "He jumped off the terrace of a high rise hotel." Matt still wonders why a successful businessman would kill himself. Carl told him if he has something to say just say it. Matt tells Carl he thinks Chapin had incriminating evidence on him and that's why he left Bay City years ago. Rachel grows tired of Matthew's constant allegations towards Carl and ask him to leave. Carl told Rachel that Matthew will never stop the vendetta he has against him. Rachel then told Carl that nothing will come between their love, and perhaps he was right and she needs to cut Matt out of her life. Carl then ask Rachel if she still believes that he could commit murder or even arrange one? Rachel told him she must believe he has changed, and therefore could not be capable of such crimes. Later on Rachel was puzzled after overhearing a mysterious phone call Carl made. Outside, Matthew runs into Amanda and told her about Chris Chapin and his suspicions. Amanda told Matt he needs to give this whole vendetta thing a rest, but Matt feels he was only doing this to protect Rachel.
Over at the Herald, Nick shows Sofia his touching tribute to his father, when Jake and Chris walk in. Nick asks Jake what he thinks about his story. Jake tells him the article was nice, straight from the heart but not front page material. Upset by this, Nick told Jake he didn't write the story for therapy, he wrote it because he wants to find out the reason for Michael's death. Jake told him some of the wall story about Michael trying to get to Vicky in Chicago, which makes no sense to Nick. Jake grows angry with Nick's questions and went back into his office. Still needing answers to the many questions lingering in the wake of Michael's death, Nick decides to do an investigative piece. Sofia wants to know if she can help, but Nick told her he must do this on his own. Feeling left out, Sofia leaves and heads over to Carlino's. Meanwhile back in Jake's office, Chris suspects that Jake knows more about the accident than he was letting on and tries to find out what's wrong with his friend, but Jake will only say that he was responsible for Michael and Shane's deaths. Chris told Jake according to sources Michael went up to the cabin because he thought Vicky was up there with Shane, but doesn't understand why this was Jake's fault. Jake says he just feels guilty and then walks out. Chris knows Jake's not telling him everything and is going to figure out what Jake was hiding. Jake went to see Nick, who refuses to show Jake what he was working on until it's done. Jake told Nick that they'll probably never find out what really happened with the crash, and if they do it won't bring Michael back. As Nick was working on his piece it finally hits him that his dad was gone. Nick finally breaks down and cries on Jake's shoulder, Jake comforts him and tells Nick it's all right to cry.
At Shane's Gravesite, Lila shows up and finds Vicky draped over Shane's casket. Enraged, she grabs Vicky and slaps her across the face. " You just couldn't stay away could you Vicky!" Vicky then told her that she has a right to be here. Lila told Vicky she has no rights and she has a husband at home. She then blames Vicky for putting Shane in his grave, telling her if she hadn't been sleeping with Shane none of this would have happened. Vicky insist that she only came to the cemetery to pay her last respects to a man she deeply cared about. Lila then told her to stop all the lies, but Vicky tells her she won't get into this with her at Shane's gravesite. She then accuses Lila of having no respect for the dead, which sets Lila off into a continuous pool of accusations. Lila accuses Vicky of never loving Shane and just stringing him along while she had a husband on the side. Vicky told Lila she wouldn't know the truth if it walked up and slapped her in the face, but Lila told her to shut-up. She then accuses Vicky of being a hypocrite swearing in front of God and everybody at her wedding that she chose Jake, but doesn't give a damn who she hurts long as she gets what she wants. Vicky tells her that's not true and for the last time she never slept with Shane. Lila then told her you may have not slept with him in bed, but you made love to him every time you looked at him that's why you're here even though your own Father was dead. Vicky ask her how can she bring her Father into to this, and wonders what was the matter with Lila to say such a thing. Lila told her the fact was you have many places to be today, why did you choose to come here. Vicky told her she came to say goodbye, if it's all right with Lila. Lila then ask her how many times was she going to say goodbye, she said it at the boat, she said it at her wedding day, how many times. Vicky then admits to Lila that she loved Shane if that was what Lila wanted to hear in a way that Lila never could. Lila told her she wouldn't begin to know what love is. Vicky counters, saying I know when you love someone who's gonna live you don't let them believe that they're gonna die. Lila covers telling Vicky it's only a vicious lie. Vicky told her you knew he was gonna live and you kept it from him. Lila ask her why would she do something so foolish. Vicky told her the reason you do anything, to hold onto Shane. Lila says I took care of Shane when he was sick during his last days. Vicky cuts her off saying she knew all along they weren't his last days and once Shane knew he was well, Lila would lose him so she kept his condition to herself. Lila continuing to cover, ask Vicky how then could she fool all those medical doctors. Vicky then told her, you lied about his research and covered it up; You may have caused the lives of millions of sick people and you did it all just so you could hold onto Shane. Vicky then adds, you may have tried to fool him but Shane died knowing what you did and what kind of person you really are. Lila then wonders when Vicky and Shane had this conversation? When Vicky was suppose to be in Chicago and Shane was alone up at the cabin in the middle of an ice storm and the phone lines were down. Realizing she said too much Vicky covers, telling Lila to believe what she wants to believe. Lila told her she practically admitted it and now knows that Vicky was up at the cabin with Shane and tells Vicky she won't stop until she proves it. There must be some type of evidence up at the lodge and she's gonna find it. Vicky walks off and Lila told Shane how sorry she was that she didn't tell Shane the truth long ago.
Over at Carlino's, Matt and Amanda talk and Matt gives Amanda more information about Carl and warns her to watch her back because their treacherous stepfather may strike out at her next. Sofia arrives and spies the wedding bouquet on one of the tables. Remembering the past few days, Sofia breaks down and cries. Matt went over to Sofia and comforts her and told her he will be here for her. Sofia told Matt that she feels bad because she was thinking about her interrupted wedding plans when she should be feeling bad for Nick. Nick eventually shows up and he and Sofia and they talk, but Nick remains distant from Sofia as Matt watches the whole thing.
Back at the gravesite, Vicky leaves unnerved by Lila's words, went back to her car and while looking for her keys, finds only one of a pair of earrings in her purse. Realizing she lost one of her earrings somewhere. Vicky tries to recall where she lost it. She's panicked when she realizes the other one could still be at the cabin. Vicky went up to the cabin to try and find the earring, but all she can do was think about that night at the cabin with Shane.
Meanwhile back at the Herald, Lila plays the grieving (ex) widow and visits Jake. She told Jake how hard it's been and how if she could just go to the last place where Shane was she'd feel more resolved. She slyly gets Jake to bring her to the lodge. Meanwhile, Vicky's already at the lodge frantically looking for the earring and crying over the clothes Shane left.
Cindy arrives at the police station and asks Joe if he would do her a favor. She wants Joe to get Paulina to see her, (Cindy). Cindy also tries to make Joe believe that she may be mistaken about Paulina and the drug use the night of the fire. Joe said he would not do that. Cindy starts to leave when another officer said to Joe that his loft was ready to move into, hearing this she assumes the truth: Joe was not with Paulina anymore.
Paulina was teary-eyed thinking of Shane. When Carl sees her upset, he tries to comfort her with a hug. Paulina said Shane never judged her and she will miss him, she also told Carl that she understands how he feels about loosing Shane too. Carl says it was as if the last piece of Ryan was lost to him now. Carl takes a drink and Paulina said she sure could use a drink too, Carl says she was sober and should take one day at a time to stay that way. Paulina told Carl she hated sneaking around drinking and if she had been in the open about everything maybe Joe would still trust her. Carl said it was hard to loose one friend much less two in the same night, referring to Joe leaving and Shane's death. Carl told Paulina that she should be sure of her feelings about Joe before leaving him. Paulina told Carl the difference between Carl and Rachael relationship was that Rachel trust Carl and Joe has lost his trust in her so they can't be together for now. Joe rings the bell to the house, Rachel answers it and Joe comes in and told Paulina he has come for his things, he has been staying in the guest room.
Lila and Jake are on their way up to the cabin in Jake's car. Jake was talking and Lila imagines that they arrive at the cabin she finds another glass besides the one that Shane drank out of. It has bright red lipstick on the rim of it, she gloats at Jake about it being Vicki's shade when in comes Vicki to the cabin with bright red lipstick on, and Jake starts calling Vicki a liar and a cheat. All this was of course was what Lila was hoping to find, Jake brought her back with his adamant statement that Vicki was in Chicago not at the cabin. Lila muses to Jake maybe she was wrong but she will see.
In the interim Vicki was at the cabin cleaning up any trace of her being there. She was also looking everywhere in the cabin not outside the cabin for her missing earring, which was out on the front step. She takes another look all through the cabin saying never underestimate Lila, but she doesn't find it. She was ready to leave when Jake and Lila arrive at the front door, Jake looking for the key Lila was standing there when she sees the earring on the step, she quietly picks it up and puts it in her purse. Vicki was inside, Jake and Lila enter and look around, Lila notices the front window was open, Vicki had slipped out just in time. Lila looks around nothing was out of place, she finds Shane's fountain pen on the table. She told Jake his research should be there but can't find it. She looks some more and finds a wet sponge. This she waves in Jake's face telling him that Vicki was there cleaning up so they would not find evidence of her being there. Jake said it was probably Shane left it there, Lila said still wet???? Jake then says it was Donna who came up it was her cabin. Lila insist was was Vicki covering up her tracks and Jake yells at Lila he does not like to be used and that he knows she used him just to try and get Vicki in trouble.
Cindy was at home telling Grant what she had done and now he was the cause of a family break up. She wants Grant to talk to Joe and confess so that Dante can have a whole family. Grant told her she was crazy that Joe would put him in prison and that he would not survive another prison stay. Cindy also brought up the subject of getting custody of Steven from Vicki, When Grant stuns Cindy with the comment that Vicki was dealing with enough without loosing Steven too so soon. Cindy can't believe her ears, she accuses Grant of still caring for Vicki, Grant tries to assure her that Cindy was the only one he loves. He tries to make love to Cindy when she claimed that she wanted all her faculties about her. Grant said loosing her father was enough for now that he does have human feelings after all. Cindy told Grant she thinks the accident was weird with the two men Vicki loved was killed on the same road in an out of the way place, and that maybe Vicki was out there with Shane and Michael went to save her marriage, little did Cindy realize she had stumbled on the truth.
When Joe comes in and says he came to get his things. Paulina was dumbstruck. Carl told Joe to use a little sensitivity right now with Paulina. Paulina recovers and told Joe to be sure to get all of his stuff, and huffs out of the entryway. Rachael talks to Joe trying to get him to stay with Paulina. He said he would if Paulina would tell the truth. Rachael says Paulina was the one child most like Mac, she always told the truth. She ask Joe if he would forgive her if she admitted taking the drugs on the night of the fire and Joe said yes he would forgive her and stay. Rachael told him that he was demanding that Paulina lie then because she would save her marriage if that was all it took, and that Paulina had spoken the truth, just think about it why would she stick with a lie if all it took was to admit to it. In the outer room Carl was telling Paulina not to be too hasty in pushing Joe out, to make sure that there isn't something to save their marriage. Paulina says Joe was the one in a hurry to move out that she just didn't think it would be this soon. Carl tries to convince her to take Joe back, but Paulina says Joe doubts her and doesn't even trust her with her own son, Dante. Back in the entryway Rachael told Joe if he walks out the door that it will be Joe's problem when he realizes Paulina was telling the truth, Joe says to Rachael that it was Paulina who put them in this situation. Paulina comes out and Joe says good-bye and walks out the door, Paulina was crying.
Vicki was in Lila's apartment when Lila returns home. Lila said to Vicki what did you do steal Shane's keys from the cabin when she was out there covering up her tracks?? Lila brought out the earring to taunt Vicki with. Vicki said she should have dropped the earring anytime since Christmas. Lila picks up on this statement real quick and she taunts Vicki some more saying that the earring must have been a gift from Jake and how he would believe her now that Vicki was at the cabin that night.
Lila taunts Vicki with the wet sponge left behind too. Lila ask Vicki for the research papers of Shane's, Vicki does not deny that she was at the cabin and told Lila she will never get her hands on Shane's research an that she (Vicki) has come up against other more worthy opponents and that she has always won! Vicki grabs at the earring and a scuffle ensues. Vicki was the victor gets the earring and heads for the door, Lila told her that was doesn't matter that she just has to plant a little doubt in Jake for her to get to the truth. Vicki throws the key to Lila and storms off home.
Jake comes home and told Vicki where he had been and with who in order to prove to Lila that Vicki was not at the cabin. Vicki hugs Jake and says thanks for believing in me...Lila stands in front of a mirror looking at her stomach and says about Vicki, You haven't seen anything yet!!!!
As Paulina exhorts Jake to stop blaming himself for the accident, Steven arrives out of breath and reports that his little brother has vanished. Meanwhile, Kirkland shows up on his father's doorstep in tears. Tyrone tells Lila and Matt he's received a handwritten codicil to Shane's will which stipulates that all of his research should be turned over to his charitable foundation. The news gets even worse for Lila as her ex-husband's attorney reveals that Vicky has been named executrix of Shane's estate as well as head of his foundation. Gary and Josie's happy reunion comes to an abrupt end after they belatedly receive the news about Michael. Realizing that his young son was grieving and confused, Grant tries to reassure a worried Kirkland that he isn't going anywhere. Toni inadvertently lets it slip to Josie how Gary was picked up at the airport and questioned by a federal agent. Lila learns that she'll have to prove the paternity of her unborn child if she has any hope of contesting Shane's will. After admitting to Jake that he's frightened about going to Michael's funeral, Kirkland asks Grant to come with them. Later, Jake fears he's given Grant new ammunition in the battle for custody of Kirkland.