Matt rushes to meet Sofia so he can tell her not to tell anyone about the information they discussed. Unfortunately Sofia told Matt she has already told Nick about everything they discussed, but assumes Nick won't tell anyone. Matt adds "knowing Nick the story will make the headlines in spite of your promises." Sofia told him that Nick would never use the paper to hurt someone intentionally. All in all Matt intends to make sure of it and heads over to the Herald to confront Nick.
Paulina and Joe happily makeup by making love and settle into a night of love and forgiveness. Meanwhile, Cindy donned in her burglar outfit sneaks into the Cory Mansion and searches for the Dragonfly Brooch. Aware that the brooch must be upstairs, Cindy heads for Paulina and Joe's bedroom to retrieve the brooch. (GOTCHA!) Paulina catches Cindy creeping around the Carlino's bedroom and demands to know what she was doing there. Cindy play acts like she's been sleepwalking to through Paulina off the real reason she was there, but Paulina doesn't buy it and demands to know why Cindy has broken into their house to steal the brooch. Cindy pleads with Paulina that if she doesn't return with the brooch, Grant will leave her and she'll lose everything. Paulina told Cindy she wants her to go tell Joe everything she knows, but when Dante begins to cry and wakes Joe up; Cindy hightails it out of there and leaves. Paulina grows even more suspicious about the importance of the brooch and starts to have flashbacks remembering that every time she and Cindy were together, Cindy was wearing the brooch.
At Bay City General, Lila told Shane about Matt's plans for his wonder drug, but omits that the offer if from Matt. Shane told her that he'll just put Matt's proposal in the file with his other lucrative offers from Pharmaceutical companies all over the world. Excited, Lila orders champagne to celebrate Shane's new to be marketed drug and tries to seduce him. When Shane was not interested in starting a relationship with her and her plans to seduce him fail, Lila heads over to Matt's.
Over at the loft Sofia told Nick she doesn't want him to tell anyone about what she told him concerning Matt. Nick told her he's already done a story about Matt and his involvement with Alexander Nikos. The twosome start to argue and Nick told Sofia he'll ask Jake to pull the story so as not to risk their relationship. The twosome go into Sofia's room to makeup and hold each other all night.
Meanwhile, Gary shows up to see Grant and demands to know why he had the Carlino fire files sealed. Grant cleverly told Gary that the Carlino family has been through enough scandal, and he's doing it to save the image of the town. Gary doesn't buy it as Grant explains how would it look if damaging evidence about the Bay City Police Captain surfaced. Gary knows Grant doesn't care two-bits about the Carlino's and heads over to the hospital to find out what the lab report shows. When Gary leaves Grant eventually whips out the Carlino file, forges a new document and destroys the original one looking very pleased with what he's done. While at the hospital investigating the Carlino fire, Gary speaks to Shane after the lab report shows that Paulina had barbiturates in her system. Gary then ask Shane if Paulina could have been drugged, considering that Paulina was addicted to amphetamines not barbiturates. Shane confirms Gary's theory and adds that barbiturates can sometimes cause memory loss, which would explain Paulina's statement that she didn't take drugs.
At the Harrison Mansion, Cindy returns home without the brooch and lies to Grant that she couldn't find it. Grant starts raving and decides he needs to handle this situation himself, but Cindy warns him that if he went any where near Paulina and Joe she'll tell them everything she knows.
Back at the Cory's Joe sees Paulina holding the Dragonfly brooch and thinks it's an Christmas ornament. When Paulina corrects him, Joe adds that he could of sworn he saw it hanging on their Christmas tree.
Tyrone walks into the precinct and sees Toni dressed in a waitress outfit. She explains she was working undercover. Tyrone asks her out on a date but Toni told him she only gives men one chance and he had his. Meanwhile Chris was telling Jake about his rekindled romance with Toni. Jake told Chris there are wedding bells ahead But Chris says he doesn't want to rush into anything for fear of wrecking it.
Carl was on the verge of figuring out Hadely Prescott was Amanda but Rachel tries to dissuade him. Rachel told Carl to leave the whole thing alone. Alex did not manage to separate them so they should leave it all in the past. Carl was about to leave the house and Amanda bumps into him. Carl leaves without saying anything and Amanda looks to her mother. Rachel told Amanda Carl knows and shows Amanda the fountain pen. Amanda says she'll take responsibility for her actions. Cass and Felicia come by and tell Rachel they were unable to find Wally. Cass was clearly not happy with the search and thinks Felicia should leave the whole thing alone. Cass and Felicia bicker the whole time they are together and leave to get help from Toni. Cass won't leave until Felicia promises to buy him some food.
At the police station Cass and Felicia continue their bickering but do manage to enlist Toni's help. Toni brought them to the last place she saw Wally; but they don't see him. Cass continues to worry about Felicia's quest and told her she needs to help herself before she helps others. Cass told Felicia he would be glad to help Felicia once she decides to love herself enough to help herself (meaning she needs to boost her self esteem) while they are bickering Felicia gets a glimpse of Wally but her runs off before they are able to catch him. Cass and Felicia go back to Cass's office and find the office was ransacked.
At the precinct Toni tries to change her shoes because her heel broke while trying to chase Wally. Chris shows up and asks what happened, Toni told Chris to never get involved with Cass and Felicia while they are arguing. Chris offers to put Toni's shoes on. The two talk about their date last evening and both admit they enjoyed it. Chris asks Toni out for dinner and Toni says she thought he would want to take it slowly since she messed things up last time. Chris told her they have been taking it slowly for a long time. Toni told Chris Tyrone asked her out on a date. Immediately Chris thinks the worst; but, Toni told Chris she didn't accept. Toni told him she'll tell him all about it. Chris says over dinner? Toni told him to call her. Chris leaves and the phone rings. Toni takes down a message and as she went to relay it to another officer a birdcage with two lovebirds in it was placed on her desk. Toni wonders who sent them.
Vicky wakes up from her recurring dream of the little girl at the swings. Vicky wonders why she keeps dreaming of this little girl. Jake says it was because it was time for Vicky to say goodbye to her past since she has made it to where she has always dreamed of being. Vicky thanks Jake for his support. Jake told Vicky to ask him for anything because he was in the mood to make her wishes come true. Vicky says she wants to go to New York for a while. Jake says he'll get Amanda to run the paper and they'll go. Vicky went to Cass's office and finds Lila there. (Lila was there to ask Tyrone what happens if a man raises a child as his own and later finds out the child was not biologically his. Tyrone did not have the chance to answer; but, told her she could read up on it if she wanted.). Lila asks what Vicky was doing there and Vicky told her Cass was her children's trust fund lawyer. Lila went on to tell Vicky Shane will no longer be leaving Bay City and she also told Vicky that she and Shane made love the evening Vicky dropped by the boathouse. Vicky seems visibly upset and when Lila continues to rub it in Vicky's face Vicky throws a glass of water in Lila's face. Vicky went to the hospital and sees Michael. Vicky told her father what happened and that Lila continues to say Vicky was keeping Shane on a string. Vicky told her father she and Jake are planning to go to New York for a while. Michael told Vicky she has to stop running from her problems. He also told her it was not fair to make Jake choose between his job and her. Vicky was upset her father was not supporting her and when they bump into Shane Vicky leaves abruptly. Michael looks at Shane and asks if he has decided to do his research elsewhere. Shane told Michael Bay City was his future. Jake meets up with Vicky at the hospital because they are supposed to have lunch with Michael; but Vicky says lunch has been cancelled. Jake apologizes to Vicky because he doesn't think know would be a good time to leave the Herald since something was clearly wrong with Amanda. (At the office Amanda yelled at Jake at Jake when he tried talking to her and later ran out of the office when she found out Nick was doing a story on Nikos and his connection with Matt). Vicky told Jake it was fine because Michael wanted her to stay for Nick's wedding anyway. They decide they'll go later. Vicky says what difference will a few weeks make?
Lila stages a run in with Shane at the hospital. Shane wonders what was wrong with her and she was very abrupt with him. She told him to leave her alone. Shane notices she was coming out of the OBGYN office and asks her about it. Lila says why else do women go to the OBGYN? She wipes tears from her eyes and quickly dashes into the elevator. Once inside she was very pleased with herself because she has planted the seed in Shane's head that she was pregnant. Lila calls Matt and invites him over to her place for a romantic dinner. She hangs up and was happy with herself because her plan to get pregnant with Matt's child and pass it off as Shane's was falling into place.
Carl talks to Shane about Hadely Prescott and asks Shane to describe her to him. Shane describes Hadely and Carl presents Shane with a picture and asks him if this was Hadely. Shane says yes. Carl leaves Shane's office and went home. Carl shows Rachel the picture and reveals to her that the sketch was really Amanda with a wig and contacts. Amanda walks in at that moment.
Paulina told Joe she's hoping Cindy will be able to clear up their remaining questions about the night of the fire. Meanwhile, Grant threatens to divorce Cindy if she doesn't retrieve the dragonfly pin. Cass and Tyrone are upset to find their law office turned upside down. After sending his partner and Felicia out to speak with Lila, Cass checks the contents of his wall safe. Carl shows Rachel proof that her daughter impersonated Hadley Prescott, then turns his wrath on a trembling Amanda. Joe cautions his wife not to trust the deceitful mayor's equally deceitful spouse. Toni was puzzled when neither of the men in her life take credit for an unusual gift which appeared on her desk at the precinct house. Promising to get the pin back from Paulina at any cost, Cindy swears to Grant that his welfare will always come first. Joe sees red after learning that an emergency assistance fund started by the police department has received a large donation from Grant. Rachel was forced to admit to an outraged Carl that she's known about Amanda's treacherous behavior for some time. Cindy cons Paulina with a bogus story about how the diamond dragonfly landed on the Carlinos' Christmas tree. Later, Joe takes a closer look and discovers that the pin is concealing a secret.