Margo comes in to Katie's house to find that she has packed and is ready to leave, to find somewhere to start her life over. Meanwhile, Mike confronts Jennifer after overhearing her conversation with Dusty. Jennifer does not admit setting Craig up until Mike tells her about what he overheard. Mike is furious and walks out on Jennifer, telling her that he cannot live with someone who does not trust him. Mike goes directly to Katie's house, where Margo tells him that Katie is gone for good. Jennifer goes to Dusty's hotel room, but she is met at the door by Meg, wearing only Dusty's shirt. Jen leaves and asks Meg not to tell Dusty that she was there.
Gwen tells Will that she cannot live with him, pretending that he is the father of her baby. Will argues, but Gwen remains adamant. After Will leaves, Gwen picks up a brochure about abortion and reads it. Celia tells Casey that she would like for them to exchange promise rings, promising to wait until they are married for sex. After Celia leaves, Casey sulks.
Susan Stewart meets Jack and Carly, and Susan examines the picture of Carly's father. She remembers only that the man in the picture was involved in something terrible that involved a child. Susan promises to check her records to find out more about the man. Carly wakes from a dream, hearing a woman ask, "What have you done to my boy?"